Taylor Swift Faces Sudden Backlash After Her CMA Awards Return — "Fakest, Least Genuine"
Photo: Getty Images via Heavy
Taylor Swift's big night back at the CMA Awards was supposed to be a victory lap. Instead, just a day later, the pop superstar is facing a sudden wave of online backlash — over her plus-one, her politics, and even her singing.
Swift took the stage at the 60th Annual CMA Awards on Wednesday night in Nashville for her first performance at the show in 13 years. She opened backstage in a dressing room filled with old costumes, with country stars dropping by for cameos, before moving to a set built around the tree from Toy Story 5, where Keith Urban joined her on banjo. The mashup paired "I Knew It, I Knew You" — her ballad from the Toy Story 5 soundtrack — with "Our Song," the breakout hit from her country beginnings. She also presented the Willie Nelson Lifetime Achievement Award to Brooks & Dunn.
But the night ended without a trophy. "I Knew It, I Knew You" lost Single of the Year to Ella Langley's "Choosin' Texas," a song that has spent a record 28 weeks at No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100. Langley went on to collect six trophies on the night, including Entertainer of the Year, breaking the CMA record for most wins in a single evening.
Then came the backlash. One viral Threads post summed up the mood of the critics: "Taylor Swift did everything she could to disassociate herself from country music. Now that it's the most popular music genre in the USA shes done a full 180. Singing her old songs she refused to sing for years at the CMSs in a full cowgirl getup. Fakest, least genuine person there is."
Much of the anger centered on who Swift brought with her. She arrived in a strapless yellow gown and sat next to Brittany Mahomes, wife of Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes. Critics tied Mahomes to Donald Trump's MAGA movement — she reportedly liked an Instagram post outlining his platform in 2024, and Trump publicly thanked her for her support — and Swift's choice of seatmate became the story. "Omg she brought her MAGA bestie with her," one social media user wrote. On Reddit, commenters called it a deliberate choice, with one writing, "Bringing her to the CMAs with you is a choice."
Others went further, with one post calling the performance her "maga soft launch," according to BuzzFeed. Swift's defenders pushed back hard, pointing out that she endorsed Joe Biden in 2020 and Kamala Harris in 2024, and that friends do not need to share a political outlook. Mahomes herself has never publicly declared her political beliefs.
The criticism did not stop there. Some viewers questioned why Swift was on the country stage at all, and a few called the set off-key and bland — drawing an uncomfortable comparison with Beyoncé, whose Cowboy Carter won Album of the Year at the Grammys but did not receive a single CMA nomination. Beyoncé herself faced loud objections when she performed with the Dixie Chicks at the 2016 CMAs. Others zeroed in on Swift's vocals, with one commenter writing, "It's insane how she has a 20-year career and still can't sing," according to The Celeb Post.
There was also one notable absence: husband Travis Kelce was not in the building. The Chiefs tight end injured his ankle in the team's November 15 game against the Atlanta Falcons, and fans online wondered why he skipped his wife's big night.
Plenty of fans saw something else entirely, praising the performance as a full-circle moment that brought Swift back to her country roots. Swift's team has not responded to the criticism.
For now, the comeback that was meant to celebrate her return to Nashville has turned into one of the most talked-about moments of awards season — just not in the way anyone expected.
Sources: Heavy, BuzzFeed

Comments
Post a Comment